Hello Chad,

I wish I had answered this question for you awhile ago but I just ran across this question while looking for the same answer.  It took some digging, but below is the answer with link to the source.

Q: If I have recertified, will I receive a new kit?

A: No. When you recertify (or renew your certification), you will not be sent a Welcome Kit. Welcome Kits are only sent when a certification (excluding CC) is first earned. If you would like to purchase a new kit upon recertification, you may do so by contacting MemberSupport@isc2.org. The fee for a Member Welcome Kit is U.S. $35

https://www.isc2.org/frequently-asked-questions  Drill into the "Member Welcome Kit" section to see the Q&A as provided.

Kind regards,

Beau Gonzales