My renewal period just started and was wondering how I might receive a printed version from ISC2 of my certificate, similar to what I received after passing the exam. I have downloaded the digital certificate but prefer the printed version received in the mail.
It's not a question of how? It's a question of when?
When you receive the renewal email, which is usually the next business day after your renewal date, you'll be told they're sending you a new certification package and to make sure your address is set correctly in your member portal profile.
At that point the information in the standard certification package FAQ applies:
Have you received your official "CISSP Renewal Notification" email?
As stated in the FAQ I linked previously, it can take up to 12 weeks for the certificate package to be received after you receive the official email.
If you didn't receive the email you need to contact Member Services: